- Common Myths -
“Orthopedic surgeons are all jocks.”
“Only nerds become internists.”
“Psychiatrists are as crazy as their patients.”
“Pathologists are so socially inept that they only like
working with dead people.”
As the
number of available specialties and sub-specialties continue to increase,
medical students – and even new doctors – are finding it more difficult to make
a choice of the field of medicine to specialize in. For some, it is even a
question of whether to specialize at all or to remain in general practice as a
medical officer.
Some of the
factors that may influence intending doctors’ choice of a medical specialty
include:
ii. Intellectual content and clinical issues/cases encountered
iii. Length of residency training
iv. Difficulty in obtaining residency or fellowship position
v. Amount of patient encountered
vi. Type of patient encountered
vii. Prestige, status and social expectation
viii. Lifestyle consideration
ix. Future earning or earning potential
x. Job opportunities and prediction about specialist workforce
xi. Whether to be a specialist, a sub-specialist or to be a generalist
This article
focuses mainly on how Personality Types may
predict the suitable field of specialization for upcoming doctors.We'll discuss two main ways to do that.
Personality type is a mix of what makes you tick, what gives you satisfaction and fulfillment, how do you interact with your peers. It is considered as perhaps the most important factor. This is because each specialty requires a set of skills, a circle of qualities, and a certain type of disposition. Some of these requirements are unique to each specialty while some of them overlap across various disciplines.
One way to
decide which specialty your personality fits into is to pay attention during
the clinical rotations. This may be made easy by asking the following questions
during each rotation and observing your inner feeling for their answers.
Would I be comfortable working with this set of doctors?
Do I feel at home here or does it feel like i'm being forced?
which set of doctors do I feel most comfortable with?
Which specialty/specialties appeal most naturally to my gut feeling?
Do I feel at home here or does it feel like i'm being forced?
which set of doctors do I feel most comfortable with?
Which specialty/specialties appeal most naturally to my gut feeling?
A more
practicable way to find out your personality type is to use personality type indicators which have
been careful studied by psychologists and prepared over the years. You can
search the internet for more information on these type indicators.
The most
widely used type indicator is the Myer-Briggs
type indicator (MBTI) which was first developed in the 1950s and has stood
the test of time with minor modifications over the years.
How Does The Myer-Briggs Type
Indicator (MBTI) Work??
I’ll attempt
to summarize the MBTI though its working is more complex than I’ll put it – I
trust the average medical student is smart enough to easily understand.
The MBTI
theory identifies four (4) main indices of human personality. Each index
represents one of 4 basic preferences about how every individual perceives and
processes external stimuli and how they use that information to make some kinds
of cognitive judgment. As part of one’s overall personality, this judgment
guides behavioural preferences in any situation involving other people – like
colleagues or patient. These 4 indices are a choice between two extreme poles
and you have to choose which pole you’re closer to. The indices (I’ll explain
them later) are;
b) Sensing (S) OR Intuition (N)
c) Thinking (T) OR Feeling (F)
d) Judgment (J) OR Perception (P)
For example
a person whose personality goes more with Extroversion (E), Sensing (S),
Feeling (F), Judgment (J) will have a personality type labelled as ESFJ.
A person with Introversion (I), Sensing (S), Feeling (F), Judgment (J)
is labelled ISFJ etc.
There are a
maximum of 16 possible personality types
from combination of above indices. That is, every individual fall into any of
these 16 personality types.
A brief
explanation of the indices follows:
Extroversion (E) OR
Introversion (I):
This is about how you relate with others, and whether you derive your energy
from yourself or from outside.
·
Introverts: doesn’t mean being
asocial. They prefer to focus their interest and energy on an inner world of
ideas, impressions and reactions. They prefer interactions with greater focus
and depth.
·
Extroverts: doesn’t mean being the
“life of the party.” They derive their energy from external stimuli and tend to
focus more on the outside world. They prefer being engaged in many things at
once, with lots of expression, impulsivity, and thinking aloud.
Sensing (S) OR
Intuition (N):
This deals with what kinds of stimuli you prefer when collecting, processing,
and remembering information.
·
Sensors: they are drawn to the
immediate, practical details of life that can be taken in through any of the
five senses. They look at the reality of the world around them, rely on past
experiences, and take things literally.
·
Intuitives: look beyond the facts and
evidences for meanings, possibilities, connections, and relationships. They are
more imaginative people who like to see the big picture and abstract concepts.
They rely on gut feeling rather than past experience.
Thinking (T) OR Feeling
(F): This is
simply “how do you make decisions and come to conclusions?” It concerns the
kind of judgment you trust when you need to make a decision.
·
Thinkers: make their decisions
impersonally, based mainly on objective data that makes sense to them. They
always consider the logical consequences of their decisions.
·
Feelers: rely on personal, subjective
feelings in their decisions. They are sensitive people who take time to
consider how their decisions may affect others. They like pleasing others and
tend to get their feelings hurt rather easily.
Judgment (J) OR Perception (P): How do you order your life? This
describes how you deal with the outside world. What kind of environment make
you most comfortable?
·
Judgers: serious, time-conscious
individuals who live by schedules. They like things orderly, planned, and
controlled. They need a world of structure and predictability to be at their
most organized and productive. They make decisions quickly and decisively.
·
Perceivers: they are more open
minded, relaxed, and nonconforming. They are much more aware of ideas, events,
and things. They gather information leisurely way before making a final
decision. They love to experience as much of the world as possible, so they
like to keep their options open and are most comfortable adapting.
Now, after
using the above explanation to decide your specific personality type. You have
two options on how to determine which specialty fits you;
1. Go online to any of the various personality type websites. Submit your personality type and wait for expert feedback on which specialties best fit you.
2. Use the findings of various studies and researches. These researches have come up with different specialties that fit into different personalities as listed below:
Introverted–Sensing–Thinking–
Judging
(ISTJ)
Dermatology
Obstetrics-gynecology
Family
practice
Urology
Orthopedic
surgery
Introverted–Sensing–Feeling–
Judging
(ISFJ)
Anesthesiology
Ophthalmology
General
practice
Family
practice
Pediatrics
Introverted–Sensing–Thinking–
Perceptive
(ISTP)
Otolaryngology
Anesthesiology
Radiology
Ophthalmology
General
practice
Introverted–Sensing–Feeling–
Perceptive
(ISFP)
Anesthesiology
Urology
Family
practice
Thoracic
surgery
General
practice
Introverted–Intuitive–Feeling–
Judging
(INFJ)
Psychiatry
Internal
medicine
Thoracic
surgery
General
surgery
Pathology
Extroverted–Sensing–Thinking–
Judging
(ESTJ)
Obstetrics-gynecology
General
practice
General
surgery
Orthopedic
surgery
Pediatrics
Extroverted–Sensing–Feeling–
Judging
(ESFJ)
Pediatrics
Orthopedic
surgery
Otolaryngology
General
practice
Internal
medicine
Extroverted–Intuitive–Feeling–
Perceptive
(ENFP)
Psychiatry
Dermatology
Otolaryngology
Psychiatry
Pediatrics
Introverted–Intuitive–Thinking–
Judging
(INTJ)
Psychiatry
Pathology
Neurology
Internal
medicine
Anesthesiology
Introverted–Intuitive–Feeling–
Perceptive
(INFP)
Psychiatry
Cardiology
Neurology
Dermatology
Pathology
Introverted–Intuitive–Thinking–
Perceptive
(INTP)
Neurology
Pathology
Psychiatry
Cardiology
Thoracic
surgery
Extroverted–Sensing–Thinking–
Perceptive
(ESTP)
Orthopedic
surgery
Dermatology
Family
practice
Radiology
General
surgery
Extroverted–Sensing–Feeling–
Perceptive
(ESFP)
Ophthalmology
Thoracic
surgery
Obstetrics-gynecology
Orthopedic
surgery
General
surgery
Extroverted–Intuitive–Thinking–
Perceptive
(ENTP)
Otolaryngology
Psychiatry
Radiology
Pediatrics
Pathology
Extroverted–Intuitive–Feeling–
Judging
(ENFJ)
Thoracic
surgery
Dermatology
Psychiatry
Ophthalmology
Radiology
Extroverted–Intuitive–Thinking–
Judging
(ENTJ)
Neurology
Cardiology
Urology
Thoracic
surgery
Internal
medicine
So go ahead. Determine your personality type and see if the study is true for you. GOODLUCK!